State recommends limits for Tri-Cities wind turbine farm project

Wind turbines on a hill covered in tall brown grass.

Wind turbines on a hill near Ellensburg, Wash., November 19, 2022. The Washington state energy board sent a recommendation to Gov. Inslee to approve the proposed 24-mile-long Horse Heaven Hills wind farm near Kennewick. (Genna Martin/Cascade PBS)

A Washington commission will send a recommendation to Gov. Jay Inslee this week on the proposed Horse Heaven Hills wind turbine farm that would leave intact more than three-quarters of the originally requested number of turbines.

The proposed turbine farm has drawn scrutiny for its possible impact on Native cultural sites and on wildlife in the area, as well as its visibility from the Tri-Cities.

With scant discussion, the Energy Facility Site Evaluation Council approved the recommendation 4-3 Friday.

Scout Clean Energy of Boulder, Colorado, originally made plans for two scenarios, calling for a maximum of 147 670-foot-tall wind turbines or 222 500-foot turbines along a 24-mile east/west stretch of the Horse Heaven Hills just south of Kennewick. However, the Evaluation Council decided in February to implement two-mile buffer zones around 60 to 70 ferruginous hawk nests in that area and remove turbines along the north slopes of the hills.

The company says those buffer zones cut Scout Clean Energy’s number of turbines by roughly half. At that time, the company said those changes would trim the projected 1,150 megawatts of wind power to 236 megawatts.

Inslee sent the February recommendations back to the Council, wanting to increase the number of turbines back to the original estimates. In recent months, the Council has discussed trimming some ferruginous hawk buffer zones to 0.6 mile around the nests. In 2021, the Washington Fish & Wildlife Commission changed the status of ferruginous hawks from threatened to endangered.

The recommendations approved Friday call for a 0.6 mile buffer around the nests, plus a 0.25-mile buffer around historic Native American fire sites, plus a one-mile buffer alongside Webber Canyon, another culturally sensitive spot for Indigenous nations.

If 500-foot turbines are installed, that would trim the number of turbines by approximately 50, from 222 to roughly 172. If 670-foot turbines are installed, that would cut the number of turbines by approximately 34, from 147 to roughly 113. More precise figures will be calculated later.

Scout Clean Energy’s original proposal also included two 500-megawatt solar panel farms on the east and west sides of the 24-mile stretch. The Council ordered that the eastern solar farm be removed because of its proximity to sensitive Native cultural sites

The wind farm has drawn strong opposition from numerous Tri-Citians because the original plan for the turbines would also disrupt a currently pristine view of the hills from the urban area. This Horse Heaven Hills matter has become the most contentious disagreement among several in Washington between wind and solar farms on one side and wildlife preservation on the other.

More Briefs

Seattle moves ahead with $27M for six community-picked projects

a group of protesters hold signs calling to defund SPD

Protesters hold signs at a November 2020 rally in Pioneer Square. In response to that summer’s racial justice protests in Seattle, then-Mayor Jenny Durkan and the City Council promised $30 million for community health and safety projects chosen through the participatory budgeting process. (Dorothy Edwards/Cascade PBS)

Seattle’s newest experiment with citizen-led budgeting took a step forward on Aug. 16 when Mayor Bruce Harrell sent legislation to the City Council that will provide $27.25 million for six projects chosen by community members.  

The process, called participatory budgeting, allows community members to submit and vote on projects to fund. The city’s current effort grew out of the 2020 protests for racial justice as a response by the mayor and Council to protesters’ demands to shift funding away from policing and toward community priorities on health and safety.  

Seattle’s Office of Civil Rights managed the years-long process, including hiring a third-party organization to manage the initiative, hosting meetings, accepting proposals and finally voting on winning projects. Last fall, more than 4,200 people voted on 18 finalist projects to select the winning six. The city will spend:   

  • $7.2 million on a community center for Native youth and Duwamish cultural education; 

  • $7.2 million on a “community-operated restrooms program.” Community organizations selected by Seattle Parks will provide attendant oversight of at least five public bathroom sites, including two to three existing public bathrooms and two to three new mobile bathroom trailers;  

  • $7 million to create and operate five publicly owned urban farms. Additional funds will be used to pay for training for small-scale agriculture producers;  

  • $2 million to further expand CARE, Seattle’s new dual-dispatch police alternative that sends mental health professionals to respond to public behavioral health crises; 

  • $2 million to expand “housing navigation services” to help people experiencing homelessness find and move into housing; 

  • And $1.85 million for improvements to emergency shelters for youth experiencing homelessness.  

“Participatory budgeting moves us closer to building systems that increase agency for underrepresented communities in Seattle,” said Office of Civil Rights director Derrick Wheeler-Smith in a press release. “These projects are an opportunity for the city to be accountable to promises made in 2020 to create new ways to get civically engaged and invest in urgent needs of our most prevented and persecuted communities.”  

Seattle first tried participatory budgeting in 2015, with $700,000 for youth priorities voted on by Seattle residents and students ages 11-25. The effort expanded slightly in 2017 when the city set aside $2 million for parks and street projects that residents voted on.  

Link light-rail extension to Lynnwood opens August 30

A lightrail train crosses over the I-5 freeway

A four-car light-rail vehicle (LRV) crosses over I-5 on the 1 Line Link Extension to Lynnwood on the first day of full-size train testing, July 8, 2024. (Courtesy of Peter Bohler/Sound Transit)

Sound Transit’s Link Light Rail 1 line will open its extension from Northgate to Lynnwood on Aug. 30. This 8.5-mile extension includes stops in Shoreline and Mountlake Terrace before ending at the Lynnwood City Center, where the transit center is located.

The new stops mean Link Light Rail now connects directly to Snohomish County for the first time. Sound Transit offers the Sounder commuter rail service that connects Everett and Tacoma to Seattle by train, as well as runs a light-rail system in Tacoma called the T line.

Lynnwood Link’s opening-day festivities include a ribbon-cutting ceremony at 11 a.m. with remarks from elected officials, board members and stakeholders. Riders can stop at the new stations in the afternoon to celebrate. Each station will have different festivities including activities, exhibits and entertainment hosted by community organizations.

The 1 line includes the Link Light Rail’s first line through Seattle. This extension will now allow riders to ride this line from the stations south of Seattle, like Angle Lake and SeaTac/Airport, to as far north as Shoreline and Lynnwood.  

Earlier this year, the long-anticipated 2 line opened, connecting Bellevue to Redmond. Also known as East Link, the 2 line will open more stations next year, including Marymoor Village and Downtown Redmond. The Interstate 90 bridge Link connection from Seattle to Redmond is also expected to open at that time, after that project was pushed back due to faulty concrete.

Gubernatorial candidates Democrat Bob Ferguson and Republican Dave Reichert are set to debate twice in September, after an announcement Thursday that an October debate would not take place. 

“I’m looking forward to both of our September debates with Dave Reichert,” Ferguson said in a Twitter post Friday. “Encouraging everyone to watch on September 10th and September 18th!”

A televised debate hosted by The Seattle Times and KING 5 News will occur at 8 p.m. on Sept. 10 in Seattle

The Sept. 18 debate will be in Spokane. The Association of Washington Business and Greater Spokane Inc. will host and NonStop Local KHQ-TV will broadcast the event at 6 p.m.

Initial reports that Ferguson “withdrew” from the Oct. 11 event, planned by the Seattle City Club, were “too strong of a description to summarize what happened,” the organization’s executive director, Alicia Crank, clarified in a post on social media site X Friday

Seattle City Club scheduled the October debate to take place at Central Washington University in Ellensburg, and would have included the participation of Cascade PBS and three other news outlets.

Crank explained that while both campaigns agreed to “save the date” for the event and had proactive follow-up from each candidate after the primary, the organization was told a “formal confirmation would come if the other side did so first.” 

She noted that Reichert’s campaign initially declined, but that Ferguson’s campaign said they would participate if Reichert’s campaign changed their mind. 

“In good faith, we kept the lines of communication going, and the Reichert campaign decided to commit,” Crank said. “After notifying the Ferguson campaign of this update, they chose without explanation to decline anyway.”

Ferguson’s campaign told Cascade PBS in a phone call that the claims of Ferguson pulling out or withdrawing from the debate were “inaccurate,” as a formal agreement had never been made.

Reichert told news site The Center Square in an email that he was disappointed about the outcome. 

“I urge him to change course and join me on stage on October 11,” Reichert wrote. 

Ferguson, the current state attorney general, and Reichert, a former Congressman and King County Sheriff, will face off in November’s general election.

Washington Public Lands Commissioner front-runners, from left: Sue Kuehl Pederson, Dave Upthegrove and Jaime Herrera Beutler.

Washington Public Lands Commissioner front-runners, from left: Sue Kuehl Pederson, Dave Upthegrove and Jaime Herrera Beutler. (Courtesy of the candidates)

Elections officials throughout the state will conduct a hand recount to determine who will appear on the general election ballot in the Commissioner for Public Lands race.

Just 51 votes separate Democrat Dave Upthegrove and Republican Sue Kuehl Pederson in the contest to face former U.S. Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler, a Republican, who came in first place in the August primary. 

After the first count, Upthegrove has 396,300 votes to Kuehl Pederson’s 396,249. That’s a difference of 0.0064%. In a primary, an automatic hand recount is triggered when the difference between the second- and third-place candidates is less than one quarter of one percent and also less than 1,000 votes.

The Office of the Secretary of State said that county election offices estimate the manual recount will take seven business days to complete. The Office certified the results of the Aug. 6 primary on Thursday.

Before this, the closest statewide race in a Washington primary was the 1960 superintendent of public instruction primary, in which A. T. Van Devanter and Harold L. Anderson were separated by 252 votes, according to the Secretary of State’s Office. (Van Devanter made it to the general election, but lost to Louis Bruno.)

The Secretary of State’s Office reported that 1.9 million voters, a turnout of 40.9%, took part in the Aug. 6 state primary. That was a higher turnout than in 2022 (40.4%), but a lower turnout than 2020 (54.4%). 

 

The Washington State Patrol admitted to losing an unknown amount of emails and public records after a data migration failure last year led to the permanent deletion of those documents.

Internal communications reviewed by Cascade PBS warned that “hundreds of thousands” of emails were potentially missing, but Chris Loftis, the patrol’s communications director, told the news outlet in an email that “the specific extent of unrecoverable emails is yet to be fully realized” as the agency has “no accurate inventory or method to calculate the total number.” Loftis stressed that the initial speculation of hundreds of thousands of missing documents is now determined to be excessive.

The issue became known to State Patrol staff in mid-2023, and internal emails show the issue was first noticed when folders for certain lawsuits, which should have contained emails, legal filings and attachments, were found to be empty. Emails regarding audits, policy changes, accreditations and claims are also missing, as are certain vaccine mandate emails.

“Importantly, we do not foresee impacts on active or past investigations and criminal records as any email would be replicated and recorded separately as part of a case file,” Loftis added. “Thus, at this point, we see this as a procedural and administrative challenge and not a challenge to our core responsibilities in law enforcement.”

Internal communications at the State Patrol showed concerns that the records management department would be “hampered in civil legal defense for years to come” as a result of the missing documents.

“Not only will we be blind to information we need and surprised in litigation, we may need to duplicate huge volumes of work,” the email read.

Loftis said the agency continues to “monitor the situation to mitigate potential challenges related to the unrecoverable emails,” but that so far they have not seen any “material impacts” and “are hopeful that trend continues.”

Asked if the agency had notified the governor’s or attorney general’s offices of the missing documents, Loftis confirmed that both offices were notified after Cascade PBS began inquiring about the issue, but he was “not sure what other communications may or may not have transpired” since 2023.

Nine third-party tickets qualify for WA’s presidential ballot

Hands sort through mail-in ballots

King County Elections employees sort ballots at its headquarters in Renton, Oct. 29, 2018. (Matt M. McKnight/Cascade PBS)

Krist Novoselić, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Cornel West have qualified to be among the eight minor-party presidential candidates and one independent ticket to appear this November on Washington’s general-election ballot. Barring challenges, they are slated to appear alongside the Republican and Democratic nominees for president.

The minor-party and independent tickets qualified for the general-election ballot with 1,000 signatures gathered during a state convention this year. Parties and candidates were notified Tuesday of their qualification for the Washington ballot.

The Republican Party, which held its convention in July, has nominated former President Donald Trump and his running mate JD Vance as its presidential ticket. The Democratic Party certified its presidential nominee Vice President Kamala Harris and her running mate Tim Walz earlier this month.

At stake are Washington’s 12 votes in the electoral college. Novoselić has said he is running only so that a new centrist party, the Cascade Party of Washington, will be recognized as a bona fide minor political party in this state.

The minor parties, presidential candidates and running mates are:

  • We the People Party: Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Nicole Shanahan
  • Green Party: Jill Stein, Samson LeBeau Kpadenou
  • Socialism and Liberation Party: Claudia De la Cruz, Karina Garcia
  • Socialist Workers Party: Rachele Fruit, Dennis Richter
  • Socialist Equality Party: Joseph Kishore, Jerry White
  • Libertarian Party: Chase Oliver, Mike ter Maat
  • Cascade Party: Krist Novoselić, James Carroll
  • Justice for All Party: Cornel West, Melina Abdullah
  • Independent candidate: Shiva Ayyadurai, Crystal Ellis

Challenges to their nominations must be filed in Thurston County Superior Court by five days after the candidates were notified. The Washington Democratic Party is challenging Kennedy’s nomination, saying the signatures were not gathered at a party convention, according to the Washington State Standard.

General-election ballots will be mailed on Oct. 18 and must be returned by Nov. 5. On that ballot, alongside president, Washington voters will also choose the winners of ten statewide races, including governor, attorney general, U.S. senator, all its congressional representatives and a large portion of the state legislature, as well as weigh in on statewide ballot measures.

Correction Aug. 19, 2024: An earlier version of this story listed the incorrect number of statewide races.

Current WA Lands Commissioner Franz concedes race for Congress

6th Congressional District

Public Lands Commissioner Hilary Franz, left, concedes in the 6th Congressional District race after placing third in the primary behind State Senator Drew MacEwen, R-Union, center, and State Senator Emily Randall, D-Bremerton, right. (Courtesy of the candidates)

Public Lands Commissioner Hilary Franz has conceded in her race to represent Washington’s 6th Congressional District.  

As of Thursday afternoon, Franz had placed third in the open seat contest with 25.6% of the vote, behind fellow Democrat Emily Randall with 33.7% and Republican Drew MacEwen with 30.3%.  

In a statement Thursday, Franz said she called Randall, a state senator from Bremerton, to congratulate her win in the primary and said they needed to work together to keep the seat Democratic and move the House toward a Democratic majority.  

“It is time for us to work harder than ever so we can flip the House, defeat Donald Trump and defend our democracy,” Franz said.  

Franz’s concession ends her nearly yearlong run to move up from her current state executive office. Franz briefly campaigned for governor before shifting to a run for Congress after U.S. Rep. Derek Kilmer announced his retirement. Kilmer endorsed Franz for the position.  

The district includes the Olympic and Kitsap peninsulas and large swaths of Tacoma. 

Republican Leslie Lewallen has conceded the race for the 3rd Congressional District seat and endorsed fellow Republican Joe Kent, who currently is second in the primary.

In what looks to be a repeat of the 2022 general election matchup, U.S. Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez, a Democrat, is leading the pack in southwestern Washington with 46.87% of the vote in early returns. Kent is second with 38.32%.

Lewallen, who ran as an alternative to Kent, received 12.43% of the vote.

However, in a statement Tuesday night, Lewallen said her focus is to get a Republican back in the seat.

“We are at a pivotal crossroads right now between strength and success and weakness and failure. There is no margin for error and we have to flip this seat,” she said. “I support Joe Kent in his campaign to defeat Marie Gluesenkamp Perez. We need to get this country back on track because southwest Washington deserves better."

Perez defeated Kent in 2022, flipping the seat Democratic after incumbent U.S. Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler did not advance to the general election — she placed behind both candidates in that year’s primary. Herrera Beutler was one of 10 Republicans, along with Dan Newhouse of Washington’s 4th Congressional District, who voted to impeach Trump in 2021. She returned to politics this year when she decided to run for Public Lands Commissioner, where she is currently leading in the primary.

Kent, a Trump-endorsed candidate, has gained a higher profile through frequent appearances on FOX News.

The 3rd Congressional District includes Klickitat, Skamania, Clark, Cowlitz, Wahkiakum, Pacific and Lewis counties and a small part of southern Thurston County.

WA audit finds Marysville School District in financial jeopardy

students boarding a school bus

Students board the bus to Hamilton International Middle School on the first day of school in this Sept. 14, 2022 file photo.  (Amanda Snyder/Cascade PBS)

A new state audit found that the future of the Marysville School District could be in jeopardy as the financial condition of the district declines.

The report from the Office of the Washington State Auditor, released on Monday, said the eroding financial situation in the district, with approximately 9,700 students, “raises substantial doubt about its ability to continue.”

“This is the most alarming audit of a public school’s finances in 17 years,” said State Auditor Pat McCarthy in a news release. “Local leaders have a financial and a community responsibility to right their ship. The stakes are too high for Marysville and its children.”

The last time a public school district in Washington was in a comparable situation was when the smaller Vader School District dissolved in 2007 after its financial condition deteriorated and a maintenance and operation levy failed.

Revenue decreases in Marysville stem from declining enrollment as well as a double levy failure in 2022, the report noted. Additionally, executive management and the school board have not “taken the necessary steps to guarantee the district can meet its financial obligations.”

Those challenges were amplified by staffing transitions in key decision-making roles, the report added.

Ideally, school districts should have more than 60 days’ worth of operating expenses in their general fund, but at the end of August 2023, Marysville School District maintained only about 18.6 days’ worth of operating expenditures. Recent audits of the district’s financial reports through June 2024 showed more expenditures than funds — a negative balance equaling 11.6 days of operating expenses.

Auditors originally set out to review Marysville’s finances ending in August 2023, but they continued to work through the current fiscal year due to “subsequent events involving the school’s financial condition.”

The Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction and the local educational service district assisted the district in August of last year, after it was unable to submit a balanced budget and OSPI placed it in binding conditions. OSPI then convened a financial oversight committee to work with the Marysville School District. 

The Washington State Library and its counterpart in Wisconsin will work together for the next three years to encourage libraries at the public, tribal and community college level to implement tabletop role-playing game activities. 

The federal Institute of Museum and Library Services gave Wisconsin and Washington a $249,500 grant to make it happen. 

Seattle nonprofit Game to Grow, the University of Wisconsin-Madison and Heart of the Deernicorn, an Olympia-based gaming studio and workshop, will collaborate on creating a digital toolkit guide for libraries to implement games-based services. 

The Wisconsin/Washington project builds on an existing program that has awarded more than 50 grants to Washington libraries for tabletop game programs. 

Wizards of the Coast donated 75 boxes of the popular tabletop game Dungeons & Dragons to the Washington State Library in March so all library system in the state could have a gaming kit for patrons to use. Break from Reality Games, a Seattle-based company, also donated grip mats to Washington libraries. 

“We are so thankful for the support from the Institute of Museum and Library Services,” Washington State Librarian Sara Jones said in the press release. “This project will provide libraries with recommendations for equitable and accessible games-based services that will greatly benefit the community.”

 

CORRECTION: This brief has been updated to state that 75 boxes of the game Dungeons & Dragons was donated for all library systems, not all libraries in the state.